On January 24, 2026, the world of whiskey collecting witnessed a historic moment: a rare bottle of Old Rip Van Winkle 20 Year Old Single Barrel “Sam’s” bourbon sold for $162,500 at a Sotheby’s auction in New York — making it the most expensive American whiskey ever sold at auction. This sale didn’t just break records; it reflected deepening global interest in rare bourbon and American whiskey as a collectible asset.
Why This Bourbon Made History
A Legendary Bottle
The record‑setting bottle was distilled in 1982 at Kentucky’s iconic Stitzel‑Weller distillery and bottled in 2003 exclusively for Sam’s Wines & Spirits in Chicago. Only 60 bottles from this single barrel were ever produced — instantly elevating its scarcity and appeal to serious collectors.
Record Auction Results
At the Sotheby’s live auction — part of The Great American Whiskey Collection — the bourbon hammered at $130,000, with the total sale price reaching $162,500 after buyer premiums and fees. This top lot helped drive the full auction to more than $2.5 million, far surpassing pre‑sale estimates.
The Great American Whiskey Collection
Unprecedented Rarity Under the Gavel
Sotheby’s showcased 360 rare bottles from top American distilleries, ranging from legendary bourbons like Old Rip Van Winkle to historic rye whiskeys and private‑label bottlings. Every lot sold, with 89% exceeding estimated prices — a strong indicator of today’s collectible whiskey market strength.
Other Highlights
Some notable sales from the auction included:
- Van Winkle 18 Year Old “Binny’s” — over $100,000
- Very Very Old Fitzgerald 18 Year Old — over $112,000
- Other Van Winkle private‑label bottles commanding collectors’ bids
What Drives Whiskey Auction Records?
Rarity & Provenance
Ultra‑limited releases — especially single barrels and private‑label expressions — are among the biggest drivers of high auction prices. Bottles from closed or historic distilleries like Stitzel‑Weller are especially prized.
Collector Demand & Market Trends
The surge in interest among both seasoned collectors and newer buyers — nearly one‑third of buyers at this auction were first‑timers — shows expanding demand for investment‑grade American whiskey.
How This Compares to Other Whiskey Records
While this Van Winkle bourbon now holds the U.S. record for American whiskey, it’s worth noting that world whiskey auctions have seen even higher figures — such as Macallan bottles in the multi‑million dollar range. These comparisons help put the American whiskey boom into a global perspective.
What This Means for Collectors
Growing Asset Value
With record figures like $162,500, rare American whiskey is now firmly on the radar of luxury collectors, fine spirit investors, and auction houses alike.
Future Auctions to Watch
Keep an eye on upcoming sales with rare single barrels, vintage rye, and private releases — they may continue to push boundaries in value and demand.
Discover more about whisky casks and promotions at whiskybulletin.com.